To what end do we pray? #whypray

I feel like I’m linking over to Tony Jones’ blog an awful lot these days.  I’m sure this is because he posts on his blog, on average, twice a day, so his work is usually near the front of my mind.  It is also because he is doing some great stuff.  One of the things he’s working on these days is a book that is tentatively entitledWhy Pray?  As you probably gathered from yesterday, I’ve often pondered that question myself.  Why do we pray?

The Westminster Dictionary of Theological Terms (clearly a book written in the Reformed tradition  taught me that the word “prayer” comes from the latin “precari” which means “to entreat.”  So at its etymological root, prayer is about asking someone/something/some-deity “earnestly or anxiously” to do something.  (Thanks Google for that quick definition).  The WDTT goes on to say prayer is “Human approach to God and addressing God in praise and adoration, confession, thanksgiving, supplication, and intercession.”  This seems to fit with the common notion of prayer as well as its etymological roots.  It is the second sentence in the WDTT definition, however, that I find more intriguing: “A consciousness of God’s presence, love, direction, and grace may be experienced.” “May be experienced”?  That’s odd.

So I turned toward Rome and looked up Prayer in The Catholic Encyclopaedia on  With the Imprimatur of Cardinal Farley (1911), prayer gets defined as “An act of the virtue of religion which consists in asking proper gifts or graces from God. In a more general sense it is the application of the mind to Divine things, not merely to acquire a knowledge of them but to make use of such knowledge as a means of union with God. This may be done by acts of praise and thanksgiving, but petition is the principal act of prayer.”

Both our Roman Catholic and Reformed brethren assuming that a key component to prayer is asking God for stuff, which we all know and understand.  What I appreciate, even of TCE which says “petition is the principal act of prayer,” is that both also are very clear that prayer isn’t just about petition and intercession.  Prayer is about “the application of the mind to Divine things.”  Prayer is about “praise and adoration, confession, and thanksgiving.”  To my mind, the most important end of prayer is that which Donald McKim couches as “may be experienced”:  “a consciousness of God’s presence, love, direction, and grace.”   That is, ultimately, what Bartimaeus was longing for.  That is, thematically, why Mark uses this story where he does.  That is, I humbly submit, why we pray.


4 thoughts on “To what end do we pray? #whypray

  1. I find myself pondering the difference between reflecting on why we pray and how we (perhaps how [which includes ‘for what’ ] we should) pray. A pink slip may be ‘why’ we pray ~ not certain it should factor in ‘how’ or ‘for what’ we pray? What is the difference between James’ and John’s prayer “give us what we want” and Bartimaeus answer to Jesus question “…let me see again.” A prayer – perhaps. … again … so Bartimaeus once had sight, never thought of this before, and now I wander, sorry for the distraction.

  2. I think the point of prayer is to reclaim areas of creation for God where he has been cast out by human sinfulness. Contemplation invites God back into broken places in our hearts and minds. Petition invited him to enter more fully into situations where humanity is broken. Praise washes people and places with the presence (glory) of God. Prayer is the real spiritual work human beings do to reconcile creation back to God after human beings have alienated it from God.

  3. I start with such a high doctrine of God’s sovereignty that I end up with a completely impassible God. Because of that, prayers don’t affect God–only us. I think you have a wonderful way of describing prayer–a human experience of God’s will, love, mercy, forgiveness, blessing, provision, etc.. If I pray for rain and it rains, God isn’t sending the rain because I asked for it, but my prayer makes it possible to identify the rain as God’s gracious provision for the earth. One side-note: I do believe that prayer can be an avenue for God’s work in the world even if God isn’t “responding” to the prayer in the same way a parent might respond to a child’s request for a cookie. In other words, God might use my prayer to bring about a miraculous healing, but that healing (and my prayer) were God’s will all along.

  4. Pingback: Why I’m Grieving Election Day « Draughting Theology

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s